Alternative mirror trial.

One of the peices of feedback i got from tutorials would be to try editing the 'out of focus' images to have a  crack across it to fit in with the idea that its the image on the mirror.
Using exsisting cracked mirror photos i got the following results:

While it does add to the fractured look of the images, i am still unsure about these images in compaired to the undeditied images. Thinkin practically the images will be blown up to fit in the 12 x 12 book, would the editing look of the images just look to... fake? I have tried to steer clear of big photoshop jobbys like this as i dont want to quality of the book to fall due to one photo not having the right standard for such a big book.  I think it works better on the second image, as the cracks were more in focus as the crack images i played alot with the idea of depth of feild. I think this will be decided when it comes to laying out my structure for my book.